2000s fashion: malls, catalogues & Y2K style - Ep 110
Before Pinterest boards, TikTok trends, and outfit inspiration showed up in our feeds 24/7, fashion discovery looked very different.
If you grew up in the 90s or 2000s, chances are your style inspiration came from a combination of outfits you saw in Teen Vogue, the latest issue of the Delia's catalogue, whatever the Disney Channel stars were wearing last week, and the window displays of stores at your local mall.
In this week's episode, we're taking a trip back to the era of Juicy tracksuits, The Hills, and collages made from magazine pages as I revisit the fashion moments, stores, celebrities, and trends that shaped my personal style growing up.
Create & consume:
What Austen is creating: I’m addicted to making these tasty salmon bowls
What Austen is consuming: Our Perfect Storm by Carley Fortune
In this episode:
How we consumed fashion before social media
Fashion magazines were everything
Before we had influencers, we had editors. The monthly arrival of your favorite magazine was a sacred event.
Teen Vogue: This was the holy grail for bringing high-end fashion concepts to tweens and teens in an accessible way.
Seventeen: The perfect blend of relatable fashion and teenage lifestyle advice.
CosmoGirl: It gave off slightly more sophisticated fashion vibes, bridging the gap from high school into college.
Nylon: A fun full-circle moment for me personally to look back on now given my time as an editor there.
Catalog culture
The anticipation of catalogs arriving in the mail was a specific special feeling back then. You would wait by the mailbox for the latest drops from iconic brands:
American Girl
Delia's
Alloy
Free People
Urban Outfitters
Rituals we forgot we did
We used to tear out pages for inspiration, dog-ear the corners, and circle our favorite pieces with a Sharpie.
We built physical bedroom inspiration boards long before Pinterest existed.
We willingly waited a whole month for new trends to drop, and we actually learned about high-fashion designers through the pages of these magazines.
The mall era: our living algorithm
The mall was the algorithm back then. There was no scrolling page; you physically walked around and discovered trends by looking at what was on the mannequins.
During my pre-teen and teen years, certain stores defined our entire identity. We spent hours jumping between these staples:
Limited Too
PacSun
Abercrombie & Fitch / Hollister
Aeropostale
Wet Seal
Charlotte Russe
Forever 21
Nordstrom (specifically to look at Juicy Couture and UGG boots)
Claire’s and Icing
As my style evolved, I started making more fashion-forward discoveries at stores like Kira Plastinina, Free People, and Urban Outfitters.
Local New Jersey boutiques
Nothing beat the feeling of finding something truly unique at local NJ boutiques. These spots felt like discovering hidden treasure:
Daisy & Lilly in Westwood, NJ
Gypsy Warrior in Ridgewood, NJ
Celebrity style icons & media obsessions
Fashion felt much more personality-driven than trend-driven during the 2000s. We watched what our favorite stars wore on the red carpet and tried to replicate it at school.
The Disney girls & trendsetters
The Disney Channel circle heavily influenced our daily wardrobes, alongside the pop stars of the era:
Miley Cyrus / Hannah Montana
Selena Gomez
Hilary Duff
Brenda Song
The High School Musical cast (Vanessa Hudgens, Monique Coleman, Ashley Tisdale)
Lindsay Lohan (especially her wardrobe in Confessions of a Teenage Drama Queen)
Avril Lavigne (for the edgy, pop-punk look)
Destiny’s Child
Britney Spears
Fashion media as plot
Fashion wasn't just content to consume; it was the actual plot of our favorite media.
I devoured books like The Teen Vogue Handbook, which helped you figure out which career in fashion you’d be most interested in, Lauren Conrad Style, and True Whit by Whitney Port. I even got to meet Whitney Port at her book signing at Bookends in Ridgewood!
On screen, we were completely obsessed with:
Project Runway
Ugly Betty
Gossip Girl
America's Next Top Model
The Hills
The Devil Wears Prada
The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants
Honorable mentions: Jane by Design (2012) and The Carrie Diaries (2013)
Trends we thought were peak style
Let's look back at the pieces we thought were the absolute height of high fashion. Are there any trends on this list that should make a comeback?
Long camisoles layered under absolutely everything
Skinny knit scarves worn in the middle of summer
Metallic ballet flats
Bubble hem dresses
Long tunics worn over leggings
Matching Juicy Couture tracksuits
UGG boots paired with denim mini skirts
Heavy infinity scarves
Thick plastic headbands
Early instances of digitally documenting style
Eventually, our physical scrapbooks shifted online. Looking back, it's funny how many of these early platforms were blueprints for the tools we take for granted today.
Facebook Albums: The original place to dump every single photo from a weekend hangout.
Personal Blogs and Tumblr: The early days of sharing our daily outfits.
Lookbook.nu: This was essentially Instagram before Instagram existed.
Polyvore: The ultimate digital styling tool, which acted as an early version of Pinterest and LTK.
At the time, using these sites just felt like a fun hobby. But in a lot of ways, those platforms were laying the foundation for the digital creator career I would eventually build.
Why we’re so nostalgic
We look back on this era so fondly because fashion felt slower with less trend turnover.
We had fewer options, which actually made personal style easier and more fun to develop.
Fashion felt deeply tied to specific memories, mall trips with friends, and life stages.
Speaking of nostalgia, I want to give a quick shoutout to a few nostalgia creators: Erin Miller, Kate Steinberg, and Nicole Dent.
They just launched a new podcast called You Had to Be There.
While I haven’t been able to listen to a full episode yet, I watched a few clips on their Instagram account where they were talking about sleepovers, MASH, and ouija boards. If that is up your alley, you will love it.
Summary:
2000s fashion shaped us all, myself included! I am curious if you have a favorite 2000s fashion trend or moment that really shaped your style back in the day? Leave a comment on this episode and let me know.
Listen on Apple
Listen on Spotify